Back to Logic and Reasoning

Counterexamples and deductive reasoning worksheet – Grade 10

Questions at easy, medium and hard levels. Pick a level and get a fresh set every time, with instant feedback.

How to solve counterexamples and deductive reasoning questions

Learn it Inductive reasoning finds a pattern from examples, which may fail. Deductive reasoning uses true rules and always gives a true result. One counterexample is enough to prove a claim false, but no number of examples proves it true.

Example: "All primes are odd" is false: 2 is a prime and it is even.

  1. Read the claim
  2. Look for a case that fits the "if" part but not the "then" part
  3. From "if p, then q" and p, you may conclude q
  4. From "if p, then q" and q, you may not conclude p

Loading questions…

Counterexamples and deductive reasoning worksheet, Grade 10 (printable PDF with answer key), page 1 preview

Free printable PDF: Counterexamples and deductive reasoning worksheet (Grade 10)

20 questions from easy to hard, with an answer key on the last page. Print it, then scan the QR code on the sheet to check the answers online and earn stars.

Download the PDF worksheet

Want a different version? Use Printable worksheet above for a new set of questions every time.

Worked examples: Counterexamples and deductive reasoning

Try each one first, then open the solution.

  1. Easy

    Which is a counterexample to this claim? Adding 1 to a number and doubling always gives more than the number.

    Choices: 3 · 5 · -4 · 8

    Show the solution

    Answer: -4

    (−4 + 1) × 2 = −6, which is less than −4.

  2. Medium

    All members of the chess club are in Grade 5. Ben is in Grade 5. What follows?

    Choices: Everyone in the grade plays chess · Nothing certain follows · Ben is in the chess club · Ben is not in the chess club

    Show the solution

    Answer: Nothing certain follows

    The rule does not say all Grade 5 students are members.

  3. Hard

    A claim says that 2ⁿ > n² for all whole numbers n ≥ 1. Starting from n = 1, what is the first value of n that is a counterexample?

    Show the solution

    Answer: 2

    n = 1: 2 > 1 holds. n = 2: 4 > 4 fails.